Showing posts with label DCSS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DCSS. Show all posts

Thursday, January 17, 2013

DeKalb Board of Education Submits Consent Agreement, Asks State BOE for Three More Months


State Board of Education members ask questions of DeKalb Board Chairman Dr. Eugene Walker about the proposed consent agreement on the table that would allow them to remain in office three more months.

Today’s state hearing of the DeKalb County Board of Education began at 1 p.m. sharp with a brief outline of the charges made by SACS that has placed the school system on Probation.  Then, the attorney representing the board, from Sutherland, Asbill and Associates, responded in words rarely heard in DeKalb: 

“All of the members of the DeKalb County Board of Education have agreed …”  

He then continued to lay out the proposed consent agreement that would allow the board to remain in place for another three months before any recommendation is made to the Governor about whether or not the board should be suspended.  

For several hours now, the DeKalb County Board of Education has been standing before the state Board of Education, one by one, making personal statements and then answering questions.  The attorneys for both sides have tentatively agreed to a three-month period of status quo to allow the board to work on addressing the issues brought forward by SACS in order to prove they can save the county’s accreditation.  

Armed mainly with the SACS report, state board members have asked direct, yet respectful questions that centered largely upon whether the board is capable to do in three months what they have not been able to do for years.  

Each DeKalb member has been given time at the podium to voice his or her commitment to the plan to save the accreditation.  Several have voiced concerns with the “interpretation” of the SACS findings, but stated they were committed to working together on the action items put forth by SACS.

“I am committed to the actions laid out in the SACS report,” said chairman Dr. Eugene Walker. “I may not agree with the interpretation of all the items that SACS says led up to those actions, but I do agree with the actions that the reports tell us to address.”

There were concerns voiced by the state board members, in front of a small audience of fewer than 50 reporters and county stakeholders, about how they individually may or may  not have been guilty of the items in the report.  

Issues about a north / south or racial divide in the county were explained by new board member Marshall Orson as being partially a part of the county’s history but also more focused upon by those who might benefit from putting forth the image of a divide.  Orson stated that one of the reasons he ran for office was to bring consensus to the board and help bring about a culture change.  He was then asked about reports of visiting schools in his district which he admitted to doing, as did another new member Melvin Johnson.

The state BOE is only able to recommend to the Governor to either suspend the entire board or allow them to execute the consent agreement. Essentially the consent order, which has not been made pubic, should be an admission of the board’s role in the items that have led to the Probation status.  


Thursday, June 14, 2012

Don't "Cell" Out Our Children! Vote NO to cell towers on July 31!



Many people have asked me about the short speech I gave at the DeKalb Board of Education meeting in November of 2011 during the public comments portion of the meeting.  So, I'm reprinting it here as a reminder to everyone that the school board elections are right around the corner.

If  you do not know whether or not a candidate or incumbant would vote in favor or against a cell tower at your child's school or next to your home, I suggest you find out before deciding whether or not that person should be able to represent you.

My wife and I have been speaking out against cell towers on school grounds since one was proposed for our child's school last year.  After it was removed from consideration, we remained involved because we felt it was not right for these towers to be placed at any school in any part of our county.

Unfortunately, efforts made to ban the towers completely left us with a "non-binding advisory referendum" on the upcoming ballot.  While they call it an "advisory" referendum, you know that means it will likely be used to determine which areas of DeKalb will be the best places for them to try putting up the next round of towers once the first 8 go up. (Smoke Rise, Briarlake, ML King High, Princeton, Narvie J. Harris, Margaret Harris, Jolly, Flat Rock.)

There will be a question on the July 31 ballot about this issue.  It will ask you if the DeKalb School system should "place or operate telecommunications towers" at any public or charter school.  WE hope you will agree that putting children at risk from a health and safety standpoint should never be an option, no atter how deserate the county is for money.  You are urged to vote NO!

Please vote NO to "telecommunications towers" at any public school and warn others aabout the importance of showing up to vote July 31, or your school or neighborhood might be next!

Norcross 2011 cell tower fire (courtesy CBS Atlanta).

*****************************

COMMENT MADE DURING NOVEMBER 2011 BOE PUBLIC MEETING:

I would be cordial and greet you here tonight, but I know you guys don’t want to hear from me, but here it goes again.  It makes me sick that I even have to come up here and talk about cell towers.  As a father, it makes me sick to tell my daughter that her life would be at risk, whether you guys believe it or not.

You guys seem to think that it doesn’t show any risk factors.  But, I’m also a physical therapist and I work in a bone marrow unit and I work with leukemia patients every day.  Come in to my work if you don’t  think something like this exists.  Picture one of your loved ones sitting in that bed.  They can’t do anything, frail and weak.  They didn’t ask for it.  But, for some reason you guys think it is okay to expose children to this? I don’t get it.

I was also a boxer.  I have been in hundreds of fights.  And every time I think of what you guys have done, it feels like someone sucker punched me from behind.  And. I feel that way every day I have to think about this.

I got in my truck the day we found out.  I got in my truck and went to my neighbors with pen and paper and got signatures.  I said, “Did anybody tell you that this was going on?”  Not a single person knew.  Not a single one.  And we came and we told you guys that and you said, “Oh we haven’t seen any factors that we would think it would be dangerous.

B.S.   There is a dirty little secret and we are going to uncover it.  You are not going to get away with it.  I promise you that.   Again, it makes me sick that I even have to bring this up.  The fact that we’ve been lied to by our principal.  Let’s just talk about notification.  Our principal said, “We didn’t know anything.  We were just told to put the information in the children’s backpacks…. in my three year old’s backpack, isn’t that pleasant?  That’s a sweet thing in pre-K.

SO…. We go to the principal and she says, “We didn’t know.”  So we go to the PTA and they say “We didn’t know.”  And at first they are all up and arms about it and then they say, “We can’t take a stand on issues like this.”  So we are left in the dark.  So, we have to continue to seek the answers.

Not a single person has told me, not a single person, a positive that is coming out of this.  Except, “Oh, the schools are going get money.”  $25,000 hush money for the PTA?  That’s not acceptable.   The cost of somebody’s bone marrow transplant doesn’t cover the cost of a single payment that we will ever get.  I don’t get it.  

And, God forbid…  (pause)…  I don’t ever want to wish any illness on anybody, but again, come in to my work, step one foot in the bone marrow transplant unit and I guarantee you will rip those cell towers out of there.

(to the board) Bad people...  It’s not nice.

******************************************  end public comment

To watch the video of this and other protesters from the School Board Meeting last Novemer, go to:    http://view.liveindexer.com/ViewIndexSessionSLMQ.aspx?indexSessionSKU=MekWaHPZMrYBy4Wd4iUaZQ==

For more details, go to: www.GETtheCELLoutATL.org.  And, to learn about school board candidates who oppose cell towers on school grounds, you can also "like" us on Facebook.

Read more: CrossRoadsNews - entry Don t 34 Cell 34 Out Our Children Vote NO to Cell Towers on July 31

Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Congress Asked to Investigate Marketing of Mobile Phones to Children

Children's Advocates Ask Congress to

Investigate the Marketing of

Mobile Phones to Kids

In 2005, privacy, consumer and childrens advocates sent letters today to key Members of Congress, asking them to investigate the marketing and sale of mobile phones to children, and their effects on children’s privacy, education, safety and health.

The letters were written and organized by Commercial Alert, and sent to all members of the commerce committees of the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives. The letter follows.

It is important to note that after this letter and other forms of protest were heard across the country, Sprint and Walt Disney backed away from its children's line of phones.  But, today the industry may begin pushing the envelope again as the proliferation of cell phone towers at schools makes the children who are inside those schools tempting targets for marketing efforts as they already have a technology-ready facility and simply need someone to place the products in their tiny hands. 

We, as parents, teachers, guardians and responsible adults need to stand firm in our efforts to protect the children and not allow ourselves to fall victim to the persuasive messages that are everywhere in our own environment.  We need to remain alert to the messages the children are seeing and help them understand the difference between perception and reality.

July 16, 2005

Dear Members of Congress:

On July 6th, the Walt Disney Internet Group and Sprint announced their intention to offer wireless telephone service to children 8-12 years of age.

This was just the latest in what is emerging as an industry trend. Earlier this year, Firefly Mobile enlisted 100,000 children for their mobile phone service. Enfora has announced plans to offer mobile phone service targeting children as young as six years of age. This fall, Wherify is planning to offer a “Wherifone” for children with built-in Global Positioning System (GPS) location tracking. In August, Mattel is expected to market Barbie-branded mobile phones. Hasbro is preparing its own mobile phone for children, too, called “Chat Now.”

The targeting of young children as the next growth market for the telecom industry is one of the worst ideas to appear in the American economy in a long time. Does anyone really believe that kids today lack sufficient distractions from their school work, that there are insufficient disruptions in the home, and that child predators and advertisers lack sufficient means of access to kids?

If the Disney Corporation and the others just wanted to give children a way to contact parents in emergencies, that would be one thing. The telecommunications companies—to parents at least—are playing up this angle. Telecommunications lobbyists in Washington will harp on it as well.
But despite the industrys rhetoric, Disney and the telecommunications companies really want to use children as conduits to their parents’ wallets. And marketers want another way to bypass parents and speak directly to the nations children.

Already, marketers are leaping to send advertisements via mobile phones. For example, Advertising Age reported on July 11th that many corporations, including McDonalds, Coca-Cola and Timex, are moving “from small [mobile phone advertising] tests to all-out campaign[s].” Children already are bombarded with too much advertising. They don’t need more advertising through their mobile phones, whether it is telemarketing, text message marketing, adver-games, or any other type of commercial messages.

Before the telecommunications industry declares “open season” upon the children of this country, we urge you to investigate and make absolutely certain that the industry has answers to the following questions.

Child Predators. Will adults other than parents be able to contact children through these phones, without the permission of parents? What about sexual predators, convicted criminals, etc.?

Disclosure of Children’s Whereabouts. For mobile phones to work, telecommunications companies must know where their customers̉’ phones are. Will anyone other than the childs parents, law enforcement officials and telecommunications companies be able to track the physical location of the child’s mobile phone?

Interruptions in School and Church. Will the mobile phones cause disruptions and distractions in church and school, or will they be designed not to function in such locations? The potential for disruption here affects not just the individual child, but every child in the group in question.

Runaway Billing. Will parents have absolute control over billing and charges, so that no charges can be incurred without the parents specific prior consent? This includes charges for regular and special services, 888 numbers, and the rest.

Children’s Health. Children are vulnerable in ways that adults are not, physically as well as emotionally. In January, the British National Radiological Protection Board (NRPB) issued a report, titled “Mobile Phones and Health,” which warned about the possibility that mobile phones could cause benign tumors of the ear and brain. The NRPB recommended that parents not give mobile phones to children under eight years of age, that older children should limit their use of mobile phones, and that “the mobile phone industry should refrain from promoting the use of mobile phones by children.”

Upon release of the report, NRPB Chairman Sir William Stewart said, “I don’t think we can put our hands on our hearts and say mobile phones are safe.”

He also said that “If there are risks, and we think there may be risks, then the people who are going to be most affected are children, and the younger the child, the greater the danger.”

How has the U.S. mobile phone industry factored this warning into its service plans? Can it guarantee that children will suffer no adverse health effects from the use of mobile phones? If not, then why is it offering mobile phones to children? Is the industry willing to take full responsibility for the effects of its phones upon childrens' health?

The move to put mobile phones into the hands of children as young as six years old is not a decision to take lightly. It opens up a plethora of problems, not just for the children with the phones but for schools, churches, families and classmates as well.

Now is the time to pause, investigate and consider. Once the phones are in classrooms, playrooms, and in children’s bedrooms, it will be too late. Already we read with grim regularity of children molested by predators who contacted them over the Internet. We read of children who cannot focus their own attention even for short times. We hope we will not now read about children abducted by adults who seduced them through mobile phones, and of school rooms that cannot function because of mobile phones that ring constantly, just because Congress did not stand up and act.

Sincerely,

Joan Almon, Coordinator, Alliance for Childhood
Michael Brody, MD, Chair, Television and Media Committee, American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
Brita Butler-Wall, PhD. Executive Director, Citizens’ Campaign for Commercial-Free Schools
Angela Campbell, Professor, Georgetown University Law Center
Raffi Cavoukian, D.Mus., D.Litt., founder of Child Honoring, singer, author, ecology advocate
Nathan Dungan, author, Prodigal Sons and Material Girls: How Not to Be Your Child’s ATM
Leon Eisenberg, MD, Professor of Social Medicine Emeritus, Harvard Medical School
Henry A. Giroux, PhD, Waterbury Chair Professor in Secondary Education, College of Education, Pennsylvania State University; author, Stealing Innocence: Corporate Culture’s War on Children
Susan Grant, Vice President, Public Policy, National Consumers League
Nicholas Johnson, Former Commissioner, Federal Communications Commission
Carden Johnston, MD, FAAP, FRCP, Emeritus Professor of Pediatrics, University of Alabama School of Medicine
Tim Kasser, PhD, Associate Professor of Psychology. Knox College; author, The High Price of Materialism
Jean Kilbourne, author, Can’t Buy My Love: How Advertising Changes the Way We Think and Feel
Diane Levin, PhD, Professor of Education, Wheelock College; author, Remote Control Childhood?: Combating the Hazards of Media Culture
Susan Linn, EdD, Instructor in Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School; Co-founder, Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood; author, Consuming Kids: The Hostile Takeover of Childhood
Robert W. McChesney, PhD, Research Professor, Institute of Communications Research, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; Founder and President, Free Press; author, The Problem of the Media
Bob McCannon, Founder and Executive Director, New Mexico Media Literacy Project; Vice President & Co-founder, Action Coalition for Media Education
Ken McEldowney, Executive Director, Consumer Action
Jim Metrock, President, Obligation, Inc.
Ed Mierzwinski, Consumer Program Director, U.S. Public Interest Research Group (USPIRG)
Mark Crispin Miller, PhD, Professor of Media Ecology, New York University
Diane M. Morrison, PhD, Professor & Associate Dean for Research, University of Washington School of Social Work
Peggy O’Mara, Editor and Publisher, Mothering Magazine
Alvin F. Poussaint, MD, Professor of Psychiatry and Faculty Associate Dean for Student Affairs, Harvard Medical School
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
Hugh Rank, University Professor Emeritus, Governors State University; author, Persuasion Analysis and The Pitch
Gary Ruskin, Executive Director, Commercial Alert
Phyllis Schlafly, President, Eagle Forum
Juliet Schor, PhD, Professor of Sociology, Boston College; author, Born to Buy: The Commercialized Child and the New Consumer Culture
Remar Sutton, Founder, The Privacy Rights Now Coalition
Victor Strasburger, MD, Professor of Pediatrics, Chief, Division of Adolescent Medicine, University of New Mexico School of Medicine; co-author, Children, Adolescents, & the Media

< ------------letter ends here----------------->


For more information about the marketing of mobile phones, see our web page on mobile phones.
Commercial Alert is a nonprofit organization based in Portland, Oregon. Our mission is to keep the commercial culture within its proper sphere, and to prevent it from exploiting children and subverting the higher values of family, community, environmental integrity and democracy. For more information, see our website at: http://www.commercialalert.org.

Thursday, May 31, 2012

From the AJC: Lower Income Kids Waste Most Time on Gadgets

Monkey see, Monkey do! 

Guess what?  Kids can waste time using electronic devices, too! 

This is a video of an adorable baby who thinks that a magazine is actually an I-pad that doesn't work: 



While this video is cute, it also gives us a glimpse of the future.  Children who have never known a world without computers, electronic gadgets and games, but how healthy is all of this "virtual reality" and why are we so set on thinking of technology as a measure of education and achievement? 

Do we think that knowing how to use a calculator makes someone a math wizard? 

Do we think knowing how to use spell check makes us better communicators?

We can't even say for sure that the metorologists on television are any better at predicting the weather based on what type of radar system their station tell us they own, can we?

Did our kids get smarter when the "white-board" replaced the blackboard in our classrooms?  Then why would an expensive "smartboard" be any different?

Warning:  an Economic Divide

A post in the Atlanta Journal today even warns us that technology may even create a bigger problem for school districts, like ours here in DeKalb County, where there is a gap in the economic levels of students. 

If the cell towers that we might soon see going up at 8 of our lower income schools are truly educational in purpose, then is that a sign that our school board is leading us down a path of e-books, mobile homework submission and virtual classrooms? 

Will they be using our tax dollars to fund an "I-Pad in every child's hands?"  And, if so, how will our already poor performing, lower income "Title I" students do when they have the added distraction of a new computer to play with? 

How will the rest of their household react to having an I-Pad to "play" with when it is really intended for the child to use for school work? 

Has our board investigated other similar districts who have tried this solution to their educational problems?  Or, are we, once again, expecting our children to be the guinea pigs?  The RF radiation from a cell tower overhead can be expected to cause insomnia, memory problems, confusion and other issues for as much as 35 - 50% of the kids at a cell tower school. 

What about Lakeside?

Meanwhile, Lakeside High School, the school that was reported by board members to have been the original requestor for the cell towers to help them with their coverage problems, is yet to receive a signed contract OR an FCC license for a tower. 

We've suspected all along that they needed Brairlake Elementary School to receive a tower because they knew they would really not be getting one of their own.  And, since cell towers decrease property values, we aren't surprised that the other schools around Lakeside will be getting towers as a means to continue to help this overpriced community justify their sky-high mortgage rates. 

Here's an excerpt from the article from the AJC's Maureen Downey.  As you read it, think about whether or not this is the right direction for DeKalb County.  And, please remember the children when you plan to vote July 31.  Help us keep cell towers off school grounds by voting no on the ballot question and voting against the incumbants who brought cell towers to our schools in the first place, like Paul Womack, District #6.

Get Schooled - Gadgets Waste Time for Some Kids More than Others

3:01 am May 31, 2012, by Maureen Downey

Full text here:
http://blogs.ajc.com/get-schooled-blog/2012/05/31/new-digital-divide-lower-income-kids-waste-more-time-with-their-gadgets/
(Click link above for full article as well as a link to the NY Times piece.)

Excerpt below:

When technology first began to infiltrate American childhoods, there were fears of a digital divide; children from lower-income families would not have access to the emerging new technologies because of the cost and thus fall behind their more affluent peers whose families could afford cell phones, computers and video game systems.

However, now that access to cell phones and other electronics is widespread, there are fears of a new divide: Poorer kids are wasting more time on their assorted electronic and computer gadgets than more affluent peers.

“Despite the educational potential of computers, the reality is that their use for education or meaningful content creation is minuscule compared to their use for pure entertainment,” said Vicky Rideout, author of a decade-long Kaiser study on online patterns, in a New York Times story on the issue. “Instead of closing the achievement gap, they’re widening the time-wasting gap.”

Closing the digital divide is not improving the educational outcomes of low-income kids, in part because their families have the least ability to monitor their usage of electronics or limit their time.
These issues are important to understand as we are increasingly urged to expand online education options for students, even elementary-age children.

But all children, regardless of income, have come to largely see computer and electronics as entertainment. The challenge is recasting technology as an educational tool.

Nancy, What's Up With That?

 
Board Member Nancy Jester has started a new blog site called, "Nancy, what's up with that?"  You can find some of the common questions she receives and her responses here:  http://whatsupwiththat.nancyjester.com/
 
 
May 31, 2012
 
 
Hi Nancy,


Keep up the great work you are doing on behalf of the entire county.


I was reading some of the SPLOST IV information you provided to the DeKalb School Watch Two Blog and noticed a link in one of the Power Point presentations.




However, when I clicked on it today, May 31, it led to a page that says, “The online application process for the DCSD SPLOST Oversight Committee is coming shortly. Please check back to this website.” But, the Power Point also stated that the cutoff date to apply is June 10, 2012. So, we have 10 days and no way to apply.


Do you know if this online application will be working soon? Or will there be another way to apply? Perhaps the website that was provided could also give the alternative information?


I would like to apply, but that doesn’t appear to be possible. What’s up with that?


Cheryl Miller
(Get the Cell Out - ATL)

District #6

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Denise McGill for District #6 - first DeKalb School Board Canidate to Take Hard Stance Against Cell Towers on School Grounds!

When reading and commenting on the DeKalb School Watch Blog Two, we learned that one of the canidates, Denise McGill, running for District #6 (Tom Bowen's District) was employed by Verizon and our warning bells went off! 

Here's the lowdown...

DeKalb School Board District #6 Canidate Denise McGill,
http://www.thepeoplefordenisemcgill.org/index.html
We've been told by advisors from other states battling cell towers that we need to be on the lookout for the telecomm industry to try and infiltrate our PTAs, Parent Councils and even our school board.  They find out where their own employees live and then encourage them to run for the various offices in the school system.  Once they are in, the companies will pressure the employees to try to further the corporate objectives even if they are contrary to their own personal opinions or contrary to what is actually good for the school or the community.  These objectives can include the use of public funds, gaining of tax breaks and leasing or acquiring our public schools, parks and other land. 

And, we heard from board member Jesse Cunningham during his meeting at Martin Luther King, Jr. High School, found here, that Verizon may be coming to our schools next, right on the heels of all our protesting against the T-Mobile cell towers.

So, we replied to the DeKalb School Watch Blog article, titled "Time is Running Out," with some pretty tough questions for Denise McGill.  Our line of questions is posted below.  And, much to our surprise (and relief), Ms. McGill responded with some very strong words of her own that we absolutely applaud her for.  She sounds to us like a very qualified, committed and responsible parent who really understands why we, and so many others just like us, have the concerns and objections that we do to placing cell towers on school grounds. 

Here is the line of questioning from us:
  
getthecelloutatl says:
Since you have done such great work for Verizon Wireless, can you please tell us why there is no cell service at Lakeside High School with 130+ cell towers in a four mile radius of the school? This is the claim of our current board and has resulted in 8 schools being on the list to receive cell towers (Lakeside not being one of them) in an attempt to improve their “coverage.”

What are your thoughts about cell towers on school grounds knowing what you likely do about the link between RF radiation and multiple health issues ranging from insomnia to cancer, with children being the most vulnerable group?

Will you be in support of Verizon if they follow the lead of T-mobile (ATT) and want to lease our school property without proper public notifcation or without going through the proper zoning regulations of our county?

Are you still employed by Verizon? Will you continue to hold this position if you are elected to the board? If so, will you admit to the conflict of interest and remove yourself from any vote that involves spending our tax dollars on technology as you may be unfairly pressured to vote according to the way that would best help your company and not our children?
 
And he is the response from Ms. McGill:

getthecellouatl,

I worked for MCI who became Verizon Business. Verizon Business (not Verizon Wireless) developed networks and IT solutions for major corporations as well as provided networking, security business and IT, advanced communications. I have no understanding of Verizon Wireless, nor did I work in a capacity that facilitated anything to do with their wireless services. I have not worked for Verizon Business since April 2009. The last three years of my life have been focused on Youth Advocacy, and Volunteerism. After 26 years, surviving multiple mergers, watching countless friends walk out the door- and the stress of not knowing when your turn was coming- I was relieved, and when given the opportunity, I re-evaluated my life. I wanted a change from Corporate, and worked diligently towards focusing my efforts on what makes me happy- which is community service. I am grateful to have a husband who has allowed me to pursue my passion which is serving my community and its children.

Before I answer your question let me preface it by saying this to you…

I am a parent of a child who was born with an extremely rare life altering medical condition. My child was not to live for 24 hours let alone be six months away from being 20 years old… She lives with this condition everyday and we live in fear EVERYDAY. One thing that we are guaranteed- is that we know without a doubt that we are going to be in someone’s hospital for a minimum total two weeks within a 12 month time span. It’s a given-
I know what it is like to live in hospitals, and to fear for your child.

I Live it EVERYDAY.

So to answer your question- NO, I am not a supporter of cell towers ANYWHERE in a general population of people. They need to be as far away from people as possible
Cell phone towers have no place near any school grounds- nor do they have any place in heavily populated area’s. We are all wise enough to know that the effects of allowing this have unlimited consequences. We have seen what radiation does over periods of time. Who knows what else might come with the erection of these towers? The damage might be years out- but we know that with it, damage will come.

Who wants to have on their conscious that your decision allowed life altering long term unknown effects on generations of individuals? I don’t know about you, but that is not on my agenda of things that I want to do while on earth.

I personally do not want that on my conscious, nor do I want ANY parent to go through the agony of watching a child suffer. Why would I want to purposely put someone else through that torment when I know what its like to watch this on a personal basis?

With that said getthecellout-
I don’t have a conflict of interest here- but if I did, yes, I would remove myself from any vote that I could not be impartial. I do have a conscious, and I could NOT in good conscious approve something that I know might put someone’s child in a scenario which would be life altering in any way shape or form. Anyone who could do it for money simply does not have a clear understanding of the long term effects- if they can live with it so be it- that however would not be me.

If you look on my website: wwwthepeoplefordenisemcgil.org, read about me, and feel free to look at my resume.


Good Job, Denise McGill, and you have earned the Get the Cell Out - ATL "seal of approval" for a canidate we recommend to the voters in School District #6!

To our GTCO-ATL followers:  If you are like us, and you are concerned about the possibility of the school board placing more cell towers on our school grounds and, consequently, in our backyards, playgrounds and residential neigbhorhoods, please research the canidates up for re-election on July 31!

If you are in an EVEN NUMBERED DISTRICT
your school board member
is up for re-election!


Get your friends and neighbors to show up and vote this year!  The low voter turnout in November is what resulted in the SPLOST IV continuation.  If you cannot afford to continue throwing your money out the window so that those in governement can spend it on attorneys, jobs for their friends and family and not do anything to improve our education system and home values, then please do something about it this year - VOTE!

Make sure you vote for a canidate, like Denise McGill, who is willing to take a stand now as being someone who will absolutely never approve a cell tower as an alternative funding source.

And, please remember to vote NO to the telecommunications tower question on the ballot that asks if you think the schools should consider them for our schools.

VOTE NO! VOTE NO! VOTE NO! VOTE NO!

 "Should the local or independent school system of DeKalb County or a charter school in DeKalb County place or operate a telecommunications tower on any elementary, middle, or high school property?"

VOTE NO!  VOTE NO!  VOTE NO!  VOTE NO!

DeKalb School Board Racers Take Their Marks! July 31 VOTE!


For more information, see www.dekalbvotes.com.


Cell Tower Histories for these districts are as follows:

District #2:  
This district includes two schools originally on the cell tower list:

Medlock Elementary School:  This neighborhood school and neighborhood association was given advanced notice by T-mobile about the possibility of having a cell tower located on their grounds, according to a report made by a Brairlake parent at a Sept. 2011 public meeting with District #4's school board representative Paul Womack.  Womack was chairman of the Budget, Auidt and Finance Committee in Aug. 2010 when GTCO-ATL has determined was the first public meeting where cell towers were introduced as something Facilities Director Steve Donahue should check into by writing an RFP.  We have yet to determine who actually made the initial request.  Womack eluded to the possibility that it was a request from the county commissoners or the CEO's office, but that is not confirmed.  To date, CEO Burrell Ellis has not responded to GTCO-ATL's letters directly.  His office has responded that they are not responsible for the zoning of these cell towers.  Yet the commissioners and the state as well as the FCC are not claiming to be responsible, either.

Apparantly, Medlock's commity met several times with T-mobile who promised them a variety of options for their tower, including making it look like a light pole or painting the school's mascot on it.  When they refused, it was soon announced that their school would be closing.  Medlock fought back with a very vocal opposition to the closure and a highly attended T-mobile meeting in May 2011 which turned into a meeting more about the closure than aobut the cell towers.  Not everyone who attended were there because of Medlock, however.  Parents who had caught wind about the suject matter of the first few T-mobile meetings held at other schools were encouraged to attend meetings on the last day.  Medlock was one of those meeting.  In June and July, Medlock made appearances at school board meetings. 

Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter group reports that Melock's association may have been given some of their research data that had been delivered to the BOE members to ask that cell towers at all schools be denied as it was the same information that these residents presented during the public comment portion of the July board meeting. 

On July 11, 2011, Don McChestney, the Incumbant rep for District #2, Medlock's district, offered an ammendment to the cell tower proposal that removed three outspoken schools from the list.  Medlock was one of them.  They did not receive a cell tower, but did end up having their neighborhood school closed.  It has since been announced that the International Community School will take up residency in the former Medlock building.  The International Community School had been searching for a home for five years.  It serves a portion of the immigrant population of DeKalb County.  It had previously been using United Methodist facilities in Avondale and Avondale Estates as well as a satallite campus in Stone Mountain.

(VIDEO) Here's an interview with Medlock's community leader Pat Camp along with Get the Cell Out - ATL leaders immediately after the vote by the board in July 2011.  Shortly after the decision, plans were announced to move the children from Fernbank into the Medlock school while Fernbank was under construction.  GTCO-ATL finds it interesting that these moving arrangements were being planned even before the SPLOST IV funding had been approved by voters.  That's confidence, isn't it?

Don McChestney is running for re-election in this district.  He was responsible for taking Medlock off the list (as well as Brockett in District #4 and Meadowview in District #3 (which is not voting) as his ammendment was approved by the board.  He has been voting and acting in a more responsible manner within the past year since GTCO-ATL has been tracking the cell tower issue.  He often works with Dunwoody's Nancy Jester, who has an excellent track record of voting responsibly for the benefit of all of DeKalb's children, not just her own district. 

His opponent, Marshall Orson was is outspoken parent and leader in the Emory-LaVista Parent Council.  Orson misled the media and many community groups into thinking that a yes vote on SPLOST was a necessary component to reducing the size of the school board and that a mandatory vote for all new members would be a direct result.  He was also the vulture ready to pounce on the Medlock building as soon as it was worked out that they were closing. 

(VIDEO) Here's an interview with Orson and GTCO-ATL leadership during SPLOST IV.

Margaret Harris Comprehensive School - this is a K-12 school for the severely disabled children of DeKalb County.  Community members did not learn about the cell towers until GTCO-ATL leadership drove throught their community and stopped to talk to people out walking in the neighborhood.  They have been vocally opposed ever since and have started their own website to keep their community informed of their efforts to stop T-mobile for putting a cell tower literally right outside many of their backyards.  http://www.briarcliffheights.org/  This group is currently soliciting donations for a legal fund to fight the cell tower.

GET THE CELL OUT - ATL recommends:
(Incumbant) Don McChestney
for District #2 Voters
Concerned About Cell Towers
on School Grounds




District #4:
This district includes six schools originally on the cell tower list:

Lakeside High School:  This is the upscale high school currently undergoing its rennovations from SPLOST III funds.  This was also an area that had many SPLOST IV signs in yards as advocates on behalf of the school board, despite the problems that have been widely reported regarding the nepotism and possible criminal mishandling of taxpayer funds. 

Paul Womack, the incumbant for this community has several friends at Lakeside, including Principal Joe Reed who was hand-picked by Womack for his position.  Mr. Reed is also on the Vahalla Group, a booster club that helps support many projects and activities at the school.  Some say the booster club does more for the school than the PTA which is why they were able to get some sympathy from the community when it looked like SPLOST funds were running short and several of their "ammenities" were going to be cut from the construction list. 

We commend the Vahalla Group for supporting its students, but what is unclear is the connection between the principal's claims to the school board member, Paul Womack, that the school needed help solving the cellular connection problems at the school and the booster club's desire for money to "finish the dream." 

It was well known that Lakeside is the school that wanted the cell towers, but it is not clear why this would be a larger, countywide school problem. And, even more disturbing is the fact that Lakeside, to date, does not have a signed contract for a cell tower.  But, now there are 6 elementary schools, 1 comprehensive school and 1 high school all on the construction list thanks to the demands of Lakeside.  And there are 3 more schools that almost received cell towers.  For what?  Better coverage at Lakeside? 

Or, does this have more to do with property values near Lakeside?  The Lakeside area is known for bringing in a pretty large amount for its homes due to the perceived quality of the school system.  We say "perceived" because that has been called into question recently when a national standard was established for calculating graduation rates.  When looking at the number of Freshmen who enter the school compared to the number of graduating seniors, the school slipped to just below a 60% graduation rate, putting it more on par with the rest of the schools in the district.  Previously, Lakeside compared graduation numbers to the number of students who started their senior year at the school. 

Since the home market has trailed off and many people still have investment property in this area, it stands to reason that another motivation for placing cell towers all around, but not actually within the sight, of the school  might actually improve the communications as well as drive some folks away from buying in other areas and justify the steep prices seen here.

Briarlake Elementary School:  This is the school that launched an all-out war (of the PR variety) when it came to their school and the thought of cell towers on campus.  They were nice enough to work with in person, but as soon as you would look away, they would be stealing the limelight form other schools.  They often "forgot" to mention the other schools when they were interviewed on TV about the subject matter.  And, when participating in a countywide phone campaign to reach the decison makers, they got a state lawmaker on the line, requested a letter of concern to be mailed to the Superintendent but "forgot" to mention the names of the other schools.

They did a great job of helping bring greater awareness to the issue, but they also did not come clean with the public about their PTA's invovlement from the beginning.  To date, we are unsure the status of their tower application.  And, despite the warnings by GTCO-ATL that the school board decision was made and could not be overturned, they continued to encourage others to launch their protest with the board.  Instead, we urged the school communities to seek answers from the county commissioners, Director of Planning and the CEO Burrell Ellis regarding the zoning and building permits that are the necessary next step in the process.

The DeKalb County Comissioners have all pubically stated that the zoning codes of DeKalb do not allow cell towers in residential neighborhoods.  If the tower permits come to them for approval, they will be denied.  However, we've been told that the permits will go to the CEO Burrell Ellis for final okay behind closed doors without public input.

The PTA was in fact aware of the T-mobile meetings that took place in May and the vote approved the towers in July.  They did decide to oppose the tower until GTCO-ATL parents visited the area and started spreading the word that the board had put them on the list.  To avoid the backlast of the community, they helped set up a formal protest group, No Briarlake Tower.

Even though we initially worked together with this group, we had to scale back our involvement out of concerns that they were reporting too much information back to the board.  We expressed our concerns and they told us that they were only advocating on behalf of their own school.  That was disappointing, to say the least, because the whole concept behind what GTCO-ATL was based on was neighbor helping neighbor and stopping the towers from going up at any school in the county. 

As the protests continued, many Brairlake parents stayed in touch with GTCO-ATL and are still in contact regarding their legal options today.  We worked together with several groups, including many of the Brairlake parents, to hold a march against the towers and then to support legislation being introduced by Rep. Karla Drenner (D- Avondale Estates).  While the bill gained a lot of support, it did not make it out of committee and onto the floor of the House or Senate for a vote.

As a feeder school to Lakeside High School and in line for a brand new middle school with SPLOST IV funds, the parents and residents near Brairlake did not completely give up on striking some last minute, back room deal with their neighbor and board member Paul Womack.  If they also end up, like Lakeside, without a tower, the relationship between these players will be even more interesting to try to figure out.  It has been noted by many that these are the only two majority Caucasion schools in the cell tower list.  It would not be a good decision for Mr. Womack or the other board members to back away from cell towers at some of the schools at not others since they have heard from the communities at every school on the llist.

Brairlake Elementary also set up a Booster Club, similar to the Vahalla Group and has mysteriously rasied funds so far that match the money that was mentioned in the cell tower contract but not accounted for.  The most concerning part of the Booster Club is that it was established in late 2010, the same time the cell tower issue was brought up, and was set up by a paralegal for a very large, national law firm that normally represents big businesses like telecomms.

Brockett Elementary:  This is the Tucker elementary school that spawned the Get the Cell Out - Atlanta Chapter.  Since they did not receive a cell tower contract, we won't spend a lot of time disucssing the history.  However, the important things to note is that there was nothing unusual about Brockett that led to their being taken off the list before the July 11 vote other than a couple of concerned parents who made the decision to take their child out of the school as  a result of the cell tower announcement. 

They went on to follow the chain of command to try to stop the tower slated for their school.  They continued to be concerned for the neighbors who lived near the other schools and later reached out to them as well.  They set up this website and a Facebook page to keep the greater community informed about what they learn about cell towers so that the information can be shared with all those whom might be affected. 

They spoke out against SPLOST IV and continue to be involved in the process of getting DeKalb's schools back on track even though their own child attends a private school now.  They joined forces early in the protest with the Unhappy Taxpayer and Voter group and have, together, spread the word in the county about the school board's plans to put towers at local schools. 

Their work on the state bill to ban the towers did not become law, but it did result in a non-binding ballot question to be asked of voters July 31.  We urge everyone we know to show up and vote no, unless you want to fight a cell tower company when they set up shop at your school or in your community.

There are three canidates running for the school board against the incumbant Womack:  Jim McMahon, Jim Kinney and James T. (Tom) Gilbert, Jr.  Mr. Kinney was an early contributor to the comments left on GTCO-ATL Patch blogs and appeared to be on the side of the cell towers.  He has since taken a soft stance against the towers, but will not speak about any dangers associated with them  He appears to make light of the subject even though we have so many tower schools in this district, which is why we are not supportive of him as a good school board canidate.  However, Paul Womack is definitely the one we do not want to see re-elected.

We are undecided on Jim McMahon and Tom Gilbert and will give you more details about these canidates when we learn more about them.  We are leaning toward Gilbert as McMahon is a Lakeside parent and we know they are the ones who were in favor of the towers in the first place.

Jolly Elementary  - more to come.  please check back.
See New Blog Entry to be dated 7/8/12
Smoke Rise Elementary - more to come - please check back.
See New Blog Entry to be dated 7/8/12


#6 Histories and Endorsements to come...
Please check back soon!
See New Blog Entry to be dated 7/8/12

Monday, May 7, 2012

TUCKER PATCH: Federal Decision Gives Hope to DeKalb Cell Tower Opponents

Local Voices

Get the Cell Out - ATL

Federal Decision Gives Hope to DeKalb Cell Tower Opponents


One particularly kind attorney who was waging her own war on the cell towers in Maryland reviewed our situation and spoke with another advocate for safe tower siting. This friend happened to also be a former member of a zoning review board, so she knew what our zoning folks would likely be looking for when and if the applications for towers were ever presented to them.


Dr. Ricky Welikis was among three parents who filed suit against the Cobb County School Board and obtained a restraining order on the cell tower planned for Eastvalley Elemetnary last year.  He went on to run for a seat, and win, on the school board.
Dr. Ricky Welikis was among three
parents who filed suit against the
Cobb County School Board and
obtained a restraining order
on the cell tower planned
for Eastvalley Elementary
last year. He went on to
 run for a seat, and win,
on the school board.
She helped us locate an important case that went to the Supreme Court of Georgia, titled "MACON-BIBB COUNTY PLANNING and; ZONING COMMISSION et al. v. BIBB COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT." It shows that the property of a state governmental unit is exempt from local zoning when a governmental function is being performed but not when a proprietary function is being performed.
This information was key because it helped the county commissioners come together in DeKalb and write a letter to the CEO Burrell Ellis asking him to deny any tower applications from T-mobile or the school board that would seek to go around the authority and regulations of the county. We have ordinances already on the books to protect us from industrial hazards by keeping these type of structures out of residentially zoned areas.
If T-mobile applies for the proper permits, many of the school locations would not be allowed and their zoning and building permit requests would be denied. But, the commissioners did mention one thing in their letter that concerned us and that was something about "unless it is proven otherwise in a court of law," then they must uphold the ordinances of the county.

A great documentary about the cell tower issues and what your government is NOT telling you about the dangers of RF radiation.
A great documentary about the cell tower
issues and what your government is
NOT telling you about the dangers
of RF radiation.
We didn't have to look far to find the backup documentation they would need to answer their question. In fact, it has been decided in a court of law, a federal court. In our neighboring Cobb County, the court sided in favor of the county to uphold its zoning ordinances and deny a cell tower to T-mobile. So, we have again written to CEO Burrell Ellis. Here is an excerpt from that letter...
"... The federal case we would like you to reference is titled, "T-MOBILE LLC vs. COBB COUNTY, GEORGIA."
In this case, the County’s Planning and Zoning Staff reviewed the Application for compliance with the County’s local zoning ordinance. The Ordinance provides several design, location, and safety requirements for the construction of towers over 35 feet. Official Code of Cobb County, Georgia § 134-273. Based on the Ordinance, the county denied the application for a tower permit and T-Mobile sued.

The court found in favor of the county and proved that the county has every right to uphold its own zoning ordinances and was justified in denying the application based on the fact that the tower proposed would be an intrusion into a residential area.

We hope you and your staff will review the documents and take these court proceedings into consideration when making the final determination. We have received an outpouring of support for this mission to keep our school yards safe and free from the intrusion of cell phone towers on their grounds.

We have united our county on this issue, and groups that might normally be divided on other matters when it comes to schools and education, were able to come together, work together and seek help from their elected officials from the north to the south.

Now, we turn this final decision over to you, Mr. Ellis, and pray that you will do the right thing for the children of our county." To read our full letter, please visit our blog/website at http://www.getthecelloutatl.com/2012/04/dear-mr-burrell-ellis-ceo-we-are.html."
Remember to VOTE on July 31 for school board members in several districts. All incumbents must go. Nancy Jester and Donna Edler are the only ones who voted no to the cell towers in July 2011.

And URGENT: Look out for the Telecommunications Tower Referendum Question on the ballot. VOTE NO! If you do not want to put our schools and neighborhoods at risk AND you are tired of helping fund the corruption, please spread the word - VOTE NO!

"Telecommunications Towers" is the name they are giving to cell towers in an attempt to mislead you. Spread the word in your neighborhood about this question so your area does not accidentally approve a tower near you! This question does not belong on the ballot and was NOT supported by any of the groups who met with the state delegation in hopes of passing legislation this year.

In fact, it was actually suggested by the same person who blocked our bill t ban the towers from going forward. It is asking you to approve something that is currently against our county's ordinances that were drafted by our county commissioners to protect your health and property!  To view the full details about this ballot question, go here.

Friday, May 4, 2012

You Are Hereby Notified: Ballot Question on Cell Towers July 31 - VOTE NO

VOTE NO!  VOTE NO!   VOTE NO!  VOTE NO!  VOTE NO!  




JULY 31, 2012 SPECIAL NONBINDING ADVISORY REFERENDUM ELECTION
TO THE QUALIFIED VOTERS OF DEKALB COUNTY.

YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED


that on the 31st day of July, 2012 (Tuesday) in conjunction with the General Primary Election, a special nonbinding advisory referendum will be held for the purpose of ascertaining whether the local or independent school system in DeKalb County or charter school should place or operate a telecommunications tower on any elementary, middle or high school property; to provide for procedures and requirements relating thereto; to provide for an effective date; to repeal conflicting laws; and for other purposes, submitting to the qualified voters of DeKalb County for their approval or rejection pursuant to the passage of House Bill 1299.
The ballots to be used at said election shall have written or printed thereon substantially the following:
[ ] YES  "Should the local or independent school system of               DeKalb County or a charter school  
               in DeKalb County place or operate a 
               telecommunications tower on any
[ ] NO    elementary, middle, or high school property?"



All persons desiring to vote for approval of the question shall vote "Yes," and all persons desiring to vote for rejection of the question shall vote "No."

(GTCO-ATL NOTE:  In this question, the term "cell tower" has been replaced by "telecommunications tower" as an attempt to hide the truth of what exactly is being asked here.  Also, the question asks if the school system should place or operate a tower when it is really T-mobile that will be doing the placing and the operating. Either way, you should still vote no.  Towers like these are dangerous and prohibited from going in residential communities when the local ordinances are followed.  Don't let the question trick you into approving something that might be built right next to you or your neigbors!  These towers have nothing to do with education!!)




The last day to register to be eligible to vote in this referendum is July 2, 2012.

The referendum will be held in all the regular polling precincts and election districts of DeKalb County in conjunction with the General Primary Election. The polls will open at 7:00 AM and close at 7:00 PM (Tuesday, July 31, 2012).



Those residents qualified to vote at said election shall be determined in all respects in accordance with the election laws of the State of Georgia.

This notice is given pursuant to the passage of House Bill 1299 by the Georgia General Assembly.



This 1st day of May, 2012

H. Maxine Daniels, Elections Supervisor

For: The DeKalb County Board of Registration and Elections

PLEASE PUBLISH: May 9, 2012; July 19, 2012 & July 26, 2012