Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts

Friday, August 2, 2013

Dr. Walker Loses Round One; Holds Out Hope with Supreme Court

Dr. Eugene Walker becomes the third of the suspended DeKalb County Schools’ Board of Education members to learn that an Administrative Law Judge is not giving them their jobs back.
Walker told All News 106.7 that he is disappointed in the decision, but not surprise. Walker still believes O.C.G.A Section 20-2-73, the Georgia law that allowed Governor Nathan Deal to suspend the six board members, is flawed. Walker went on to say, “Judge Wood was fair in allowing us to present our case, but he was also clear that he was bound by that law”. At this point Walker says he will just have to wait on the outcome of the constitutionality challenge of the suit that’s now in the hands of the Georgia Supreme Court.  Chief Administrative Law Judge Maxwell Wood ruled Thursday against Walker’s reinstatement request to be reappointed to his elected seat.
Last week Judge Wood ruled against suspended board members Sarah Copelin-Wood and Dr. Pam Speaks. Two other board members, Jesse “Jay” Cunningham and Donna Elder still await the Judge’s decision. The sixth board member, Nancy Jester, resigned her seat in February and was not a candidate for reinstatement.
In February Governor Nathan Deal suspended six of the nine school board members after the district’s accreditation was placed on probation by Southern Association of Colleges and Schools, SACS over governance, financial and student performance issues.
Since then, the remaining three board members, Interim Superintendent Michael Thurmond, and the six new governor appointed members have been in place working hard to save the district’s accreditation. Their efforts were reviewed in May.
In July the DeKalb County School system received a report from AdvancED, the parent company of SACS, stating that the district has made “recognizable progress” in addressing the issue raised by SACS late last year. At that time there were 11 required actions that have to be corrected in order for the district to regain unconditional accreditation.
While AdvancEd is remaining cautionary in its views, right now the district appears to be making progress.
However, Eugene Walker maintains that since he was elected by the people, the Governor’s board suspension actions was illegal.
So one question on the minds of many DeKalb residents now is: What kind of impact, if any, could the Georgia Supreme Court’s decision have on the new DeKalb board and its progress?
DeKalb County students return to school on Monday, August 12.

Please leave respectful comments below:

Monday, February 4, 2013

Is the U.S. in Denial? Italian Supreme Court Says Cell Phones Can Cause Cancer


Italian Supreme Court Rules Cell Phones Can Cause Cancer

This significant ruling may change everything you thought you knew about the safety of wireless.




What are the implications of this ruling for the United States?

Contrary to the denials of many heath agencies in the U.S. and in some other countries, the Italian Supreme Court has recognized a “causal” link between heavy mobile phone use and brain tumor risk in a worker’s compensation case.
The Italian courts dismissed research co-financed by the mobile phone industry including the WHO Interphone study due to concerns about conflict of interest.  Instead, the courts relied on independent research conducted by Lennart Hardell and his colleagues in Sweden which showed consistent evidence of increased brain tumor risk associated with long term mobile phone use. 

The business executive had used a cell phone for business, holding it on the same side of his head for 5-7 hours per day, for many years, before learning he had a brain tumor.  He had very few other risk factors and no family history of cancer.  He filed a Worker's Compensation Claim.  It was denied.  He sued and won.  And now, the Supreme Court has upheld the decision made by the lower court.  

On May 31, 2011, just after the DeKalb School Board had announced their intentions to put cell phone towers at 12 school campuses, but before they actually took a vote, the World Health Organization (WHO) classified radiofrequency energy, including cell phone radiation, as “possibly carcinogenic” in humans.  The 31 researchers convened by the WHO, considered to be among the very best in the world, relied heavily upon the Hardell research as well.

Are they hiding the truth from us?
It has been noted by many experts that research co-financed by the telecom industry over the past decade has been unlikely to report evidence of tumor risk.  In addition, industry-funded research has been reported to use methodology that is substandard compared to independently-funded research. Moreover, in more recently published research, authors of studies co-financed by the industry have dismissed the evidence of increased brain tumor risk they found in children as well as adults.
This issue raises concerns that conflicts of interest may have affected the conduct of the research and biased the reporting of it. Governments need to find a way to fund cell phone radiation research that is independent of the telecom industry in order to avoid even the appearance of a conflict of interest.

Why Can't We Find a Way?
Since there are now more than 330 million cell phone subscribers in the U.S., an annual fee of only 50 cents on each cell phone would generate sufficient resources to fund high quality, independent research.  Then, the government and the industry could work together to promote safer technology development and fund community education programs about safer cell phone use.
Although 12 nations and the European Union have issued precautionary health warnings regarding mobile phone use, the U.S. has been in denial. The Telecom industry has blocked numerous attempts to pass cell phone warning legislation at the Federal, state, and city level. The industry even refused to support a bill in the California legislature by Senator Mark Leno that would simply remind consumers to read the safety information that is currently printed in their cell phone user manuals.
Only one city has been able to overcome intense lobbying by the Telecom industry. San Francisco adopted cell phone “right to know” legislation two years ago, but the Telecom industry (i.e., CTIA-The Wireless Association) blocked implementation of this law by filing a lawsuit claiming that the court-approved fact sheet violates the industry’s First Amendment rights. The CTIA also moved its annual conference from San Francisco to punish the city.

The Victims Will Have Their Day in Court
The evidence of harm from cell phone radiation has been increasing so it is only a matter of time before lawsuits filed in U.S. courts by cell phone radiation victims will be successful. The Insurance industry will not provide product liability insurance due to concerns that juries will find that the Telecom industry has behaved much like the Tobacco and Asbestos industries. So the Telecom industry could be faced with paying huge damages to individuals and governments.

What the Telecom Industry Could Do ...
The Telecom industry could become good corporate citizens, reduce potential product liability and protect consumers’ health by allowing the FCC to adopt stronger regulations, by promoting precautionary safety warnings and by encouraging government to support independent research to promote safer wireless technologies.
Otherwise taxpayers may be forced to bail out yet another industry too big to fail.