Saturday, September 15, 2012

Georgia Legislators with ALEC Ties


From the website:  www.ALECexposed.com these are some facts about ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council.  These are the folks who believe big corporations should have the same rights as citizens and that our elected officials should pass legislation to protect them, not us.  And, they can get them to do just that  - for a price.








About ALEC
ALEC is a corporate bill mill. It is not just a lobby or a front group; it is much more powerful than that. Through ALEC, corporations hand state legislators their wishlists to benefit their bottom line. Corporations fund almost all of ALEC's operations. They pay for a seat on ALEC task forces where corporate lobbyists and special interest reps vote with elected officials to approve “model” bills. Learn more at the Center for Media and Democracy's ALECexposed.org, and check out breaking news on our PRWatch.org site.

(click article headline for full story)

Legislator who has cut ties to ALEC:  Georgia
  • Sen. Nan Orrock (D-Atlanta) - In a statement to the citizens’ action group Better Georgia on April 17, 2012, Orrock denounced ALEC, calling it “radical,” “dangerous” and accused it of “impeding democracy.”[1]
“As a member of the American Legislative Exchange Council for several years, having joined ALEC with the primary goal of better understanding the corporate-dominated organization, I know first-hand that ALEC is not the innocuous organization it claims to be,” Orrock said.[1]
 
References
  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 David Ferguson, Georgia lawmaker quits ALEC, calls it ‘radical’ group with ‘dangerous agenda’, Raw Story, April 17, 2012, accessed April 2012

Legislators currently with ties to ALEC:  Georgia

House of Representatives

(Gwinnett - Lilburn) He serves on the following committees for the Georgia State Assembly: Appropriations, Economic Development and Tourism (Vice Chairman), Education and Rules.[1]

Casas is a member of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) and on their Education Task Force, as of July 2011 (the same month as the cell tower vote in DeKalb County by our Board of Education).
 
He won the ALEC 2008 Legislator of the Year Award.[2][3]
Jan Jones is an elected state representative in the U.S. state of Georgia. She serves in the Georgia assembly, which meets in the Capitol building in Atlanta. Her constituents include some of the northern Atlanta suburbs in Georgia's 46th district including parts of Milton and parts of Roswell and Alpharetta. She is a Republican and is currently the majority Speaker Pro Tempore. While in the legislature, she has focused on several initiatives, most notably spearheading the creation of two north Fulton county cities, Milton and Johns Creek.  Outside the legislature, Representative Jones is a former marketing executive. While at HBO, she served as a marketing director for 6 years and as an auditor and analyst for 2 years.

Senate

First elected to the Georgia House of Representatives in 1998, Fran Millar is presently serving those in his district through membership on several House committees. He holds membership in the Health and Human Services, Rules, and Economic Development and Tourism Committees.  
 Millar is also presently serving as the Vice Chairman of the Education Committee.  In past years, Millar served as the Treasurer of the DeKalb Delegation.
Senator John Albers (born 1972), a Republican, represents Georgia District 56 in the State Senate. State Senate district 56 is located in North Fulton County and Southeast Cherokee County covering all of Roswell and Mountain Park and parts of the cities of: Sandy Springs, Johns Creek, Alpharetta, Milton and Woodstock, Georgia.

Former Legislators

References
  1. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Sourcebook, annual organizational publication, 1995
  2. ↑ Mark Hatfield, About Mark, state senate campaign website, accessed July 23, 2012
  3. ↑ 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 3.10 3.11 3.12 3.13 3.14 American Legislative Exchange Council, Letter to Robert C. Byrd and Nancy Pelosi RE: Federal health reform efforts, June 24, 2009
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 American Legislative Exchange Council, "ALEC State Chairmen, organization website, accessed April 2012
  5. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Communications and Technology Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  6. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, International and Federal Relations Task Force meeting and Federal Relations Working Group, meeting agenda and materials, August 4, 2011, on file with CMD
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 American Legislative Exchange Council, "Solutions for the States," 38th Annual Meeting agenda, on file with CMD, August 3-6, 2011
  8. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Commerce, Insurance, and Economic Development Task Force Membership Directory, August 2010, obtained and released by Common Cause
  9. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Education Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  10. ↑ organizational member spreadsheet, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  11. ↑ organizational member spreadsheet, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 American Legislative Exchange Council, organizational task force membership directory, June 30, 2011, p. 31, obtained and released by Common Cause April 2012
  13. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, [http://www.commoncause.org/atf/cf/%7BFB3C17E2-CDD1-4DF6-92BE-BD4429893665%7D/tax_35-daymailing_stfs2011_updated%20Ohio.pdf – Full Name and Address], Tax and Fiscal Policy Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  14. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Health and Human Services Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  15. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, International Relations Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  16. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, International Relations Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  17. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, International Relations Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  18. ↑ 18.0 18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 American Legislative Exchange Council, Public Safety & Elections Task Force 2011 Spring Task Force Summit April 29, 2011 Minutes, organizational document, June 30, 2011, p. 5, obtained and released by Common Cause April 2012
  19. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Public Safety Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  20. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Health and Human Services Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  21. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Health and Human Services Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  22. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Membership Directory, December 2010, obtained and released by Common Cause
  23. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Membership Directory, December 2010, obtained and released by Common Cause
  24. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Health and Human Services Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  25. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Education Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  26. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Education Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  27. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, organizational task force membership directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  28. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, organizational task force membership directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  29. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, organizational task force membership directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  30. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Education Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  31. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Membership Directory, December 2010, obtained and released by Common Cause
  32. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Membership Directory, December 2010, obtained and released by Common Cause
  33. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, International Relations Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  34. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Communications and Technology Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  35. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Communications and Technology Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  36. ↑ 36.0 36.1 American Legislative Exchange Council, Letter to Senate Majority Leader Reid, RE: the EPA’s plan to regulate greenhouse gases under the Clean Air Act, March 10, 2010
  37. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, State Chairmen, document exposed by the Center for Media and Democracy, July 13, 2011
  38. ↑ DonBalfour.com, Meet Don, accessed March 19, 2012.
  39. ↑ member spreadsheet, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  40. ↑ member spreadsheet, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  41. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Health and Human Services Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  42. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Health and Human Services Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  43. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Energy, Environment and Agriculture Task Force Membership Directory, December 2010, obtained and released by Common Cause
  44. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Education Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  45. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Communications and Technology Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  46. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Communications and Technology Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  47. ↑ David Ferguson, Georgia lawmaker quits ALEC, calls it ‘radical’ group with ‘dangerous agenda’, Raw Story, April 17, 2012, accessed April 2012
  48. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, [http://www.commoncause.org/atf/cf/%7BFB3C17E2-CDD1-4DF6-92BE-BD4429893665%7D/tax_35-daymailing_stfs2011_updated%20Ohio.pdf – Full Name and Address], Tax and Fiscal Policy Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  49. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Director – Full Name and Address, organizational task force membership directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  50. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Director – Full Name and Address, organizational task force membership directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  51. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, Education Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  52. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, International Relations Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  53. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Directory – Full Name and Address, International Relations Task Force Membership Directory, August 2011, obtained and released by Common Cause
  54. ↑ American Legislative Exchange Council, Inside ALEC, organizational newsletter, June 2012, on file with CMD
  55. ↑ State of Georgia. Congressman Tom Graves. Government website. Accessed August 8, 2011.

Singer Sheryl Crow Blames Cell Phone for her Brain Tumor

From the new talk show: "Katie," hosted by Katie Couric.
From the Sept. 10, 2012, New York Daily News:

Sheryl Crow suspects that the benign brain tumor she was diagnosed with late last year was caused by cell phone use, People magazine reported.

Crow said on the new talk show Katie that doctors have not told her that her tumor was caused by cell phone use, but she has "the theory that it's possible that it's related to that. I [used to spend] hours on the old archaic cell phones."

People reported Crow, who says the tumor is in a part of her brain near where she often held her phone, says she started to suspect something was wrong when she began spacing out on stage, forgetting lyrics and generally feeling "mushy."

But is Crow right? Is it a fact that cell phones can cause cancer?

According to numerous studies and even an official classification from the World Health Organization: We're not totally sure.

The WHO's International Agency for Research on Cancer said last year that cell phone radiation is "possibly carcinogenic," meaning that cell phone use might be associated with brain tumor risk, specifically for glioma.

"The evidence, while still accumulating, is strong enough to support a conclusion and the 2B classification," Dr. Jonathan Samet, a scientist at the University of Southern California who chaired the working group, said in a statement.

From KTLA in Los Angeles: 
Can the Radiation from Cell Phones Cause Cancer?

Doctors say you should limit cell phone use around children as their developing brains are not fully developed and they are more susceptible to cancer.

Monday, September 10, 2012

T-mobile’s Time in DeKalb County Runs Out

Photo credit:  sabotagefilmgroup.com

Residents near the Margaret Harris
Comprehensive School were among
the many who opposed the cell towers
as soon as they learned what the
DeKalb BOE was attempting to do
to their small residential area as well
as the disabled children who come to
their school from all over DeKalb County.
Cell Tower Opponents Claim Victory!
 (click headline for full story and links to relevent video)

At GTCO-ATL, we have been following this controversy since we first learned about it in May 2011.  However, if you have news or information to share that we are not aware of that might help us complete the full picture of this attempt by the DeKalb County School Board to deceive the public as well as go around our commissioners, please email us at sayno2celltowers@yahoo.com.  Your name will not be published.


According to GTCO-ATL’s understanding of the T-mobile contract, and professional opinion of several attorneys we have consulted with regarding this matter, the extended deadline for T-mobile to secure permits and complete construction has passed. 

(please click headline for more...)

What does this mean?  Well, as long as everyone is following the letter of the law, it appears that no cell towers will be going up at ANY of our DeKalb County public schools, at least not in the immediate future under the agreement that was voted on during the infamous July 11, 2011 work session.

It was just prior to the board's vote that then-Interim Superintendent Ramona Tyson checked with the school system's legal council and confirmed that the "official signature would be affixed" to the contract on the next business day following the vote.  And, then-Director of Facilities Steve Donahue, a former principal with an admittedly limited amount of experience or knowledge of the construction industry, confirmed to the board that T-mobile would have two periods of "due diligence" of six months each.  That would mean the ending of these two periods would have been July 12, 2012, a full year after the contract was approved and signature affixed.

Therefore, if Mr. Donahue was being truthful about the contracts' contents, and we believe he was because we have read the contract carefully and it is consistent with his remarks, then the public property at each of the 9 schools is no longer legally available to T-mobile for the purpose of operating or placing a telecommunications tower.

And, it is a good thing these towers were not approved as the documents that Steve Donahue DID review and post publically were out of date.  The towers being planned for our schools were not up to the specifications required by the industry and would have a higher liklihood of falling over under certain wind conditions as they were planned with "Rev F" technology which is outdated.  The industry now supports "Rev G" or higher.  We  hope this, among other factors, and the local zoning laws were the reasons that any applications, if they were ever submitted, were not approved by the CEO of DeKalb, Burrell Ellis, or the county commissioners.

Steve Donahue, Director of Facilities Management for DCSS
requests that the board approve the cell towers in July 2011.

Congratulations Get the Cell Out followers!  You have helped us every step of the way by keeping this issue in the limelight with the media, talking about it within your own neighborhoods, responding to comments on various blogs, exposing the astroturfers and blog trolls, speaking out at nearly every single school board meeting for a year straight, speaking out at multiple DeKalb County Board of Commissioners meetings and, most of all, by working together. 

We ALL did this together.  If you were personally involved in this fight, remain on alert for any construction signs, but we believe, at least for now, that the towers will not go up at ANY school in ANY neighborhood, just as our county ordinances were written to ensure. 










"There comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular, but he must do it because Conscience tells him it is right." 

                                               -- Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. 

For more inspiration from the words of Dr. King, see Wikiquotes here.


For the truth behind the T-mobile Towers:  Please read the portions of the transcript below from the school board meeting in which the vote took place and judge for yourself.

Or, click the video link below, and skip ahead to 2:42:40 in the video for the full lead-in to the discussion, or to 2:46:46 in the video for the beginning of the discussion about the permitting and construction plans and the two periods of due diligence that we believe expired on July 12 of this year.

Video link: 
http://view.liveindexer.com/ViewIndexSessionSLMQ.aspx?indexSessionSKU=lCRWdFhr4yIvXvAIzyBkTA%3d%3d
 








2:42:40 in the video:
Paul Womack
(DCSS Board Member and Filling in for Tom Bowen as Chairman for this Meeting.  Also, Chairman of the Finance Committee that initiated the cell tower request): T-mobile Wireless Placement Approval.
Steve Donahue (Director of Facilities, DCSS): names all 12 schools and asks for the approval.
Womack: Motion by Walker, Seconded by Speaks
Don McChesney (DCSS Board Member): Amendment, please. Remove Meadowview, Brockett, Medlock.
Womack:  Dr. Speaks? There’s a second. We need to vote on substitute motion first. Ms. Edler?
Donna Edler (DCSS Board Member): Could Mr. McChesney elaborate on his motion and why that is being made at this time?
McChesney:  We have heard of two communities that I’ve heard of (Brockett, Medlock), and another mentioned by a board member (Meadowview by DCSS Board Member Sarah Copeland-Woods). These communities have made it clear what they want and I’m supporting their decision.

(Later vote was 7 - 1 - 1 in favor of the ammendment with Edler against and Bowen absent.  The ammendment passed.)

2:46:46 in the video:
Pam Speaks
(DCSS Board Member):  I wanted to know whether there’s a grace period. Just because you haven’t heard from a community doesn’t mean they are in support or not in support of something. There are still people who may have concerns. Is there a window of time, that they would have a mechanism of letting the district know?

Ramona Tyson (Interim DCSS Superintendent):  Only grace period is to pull the item. I want to ask council … The way I understood is that tonight’s approval is a contract to proceed. Is that correct? (she looks at DCSS legal counsel and she gets a yes.)

Womack: I thought there was a 6 month window.

Donahue (returns to the podium):  T-mobile has 6 months to act on the request tonight. They have to do the due diligence work to go out and get the soil samples, get the proper permits, get the proper approvals, get everything approved through zoning. If that doesn’t happen in six months, we’ve allotted one option of an additional 6 months. If that doesn’t occur, whatever sites have not been permitted and constructed are no longer available to be used.


Womack:
  Uh, thank you.

Tyson:   Once the signature protocol is affixed to the contract, it is a binding contract is that correct?  (asks Gen. council and again gets a yes.)

(more discussion and then the vote, 6 - 2 - 1 in favor.  Edler, Jester opposed.  Bowen absent so recorded as abstained.)
Facts

The VOTE took place July 11, 2011. The memo to proceed was signed July 12, 2011 (as confirmed via Open Records Request by GTCO-ATL).

The end of the 1st 6 months due diligence period was Jan. 12, 2012. The end of the 2nd 6 months due diligence period was July 12, 2012.

Therefore: As of July 13, 2012: The DeKalb County local school properties agreed to by lease, but not properly permitted by the county of DeKalb, are “NO LONGER AVAILABLE TO BE USED!”

Leases No Longer Valid   

This conclusion is per Steve Donahue’s own explanation of the contract terms to the BOE at the time the vote took place. It is also backed up by facts that have been obtained by Open Records Requests by Get the Cell Out - Atlanta Chapter to the school board and/or county for the documentation that verifies these claims.

The FCC Telecommunications Act of 1996 (Sec. 704) states that a local authority cannot discriminate among providers when zoning for cell towers.  If DeKalb's school board attempts to claim that the contracts were not official until December 2011, they would be in violation of federal law by allowing T-mobile more time than other tower companies are given in order to secure their permits because we have documented proof that they were on campuses perfoming tests of the area as early as September 2011. They would (or should) be in trouble with the FCC and the federal government if they are allowing T-mobile extra time not in their contract in order to get local zoning variances approved as this is not a courtesy made available to other such companies and would be an unfair discrimination between providers.

If you see or hear of any construction at any school site that may be linked to the cell tower contracts, please report it to local law enforcement as the company on school grounds may very well be acting upon a contract that is no longer legally binding.  They may have no legal rights to be on the school grounds at all. 

You can also report the activity to GTCO-ATL and we will contact legal representation for immediate action. We can be reached at sayno2celltowers@yahoo.com.

Saturday, September 8, 2012

Ethics Update from Rep. Scott Holcomb

The following text was a part of an email sent to the "Friends of Scott Holcomb" group today, Sept. 8.  State Representative Holcomb represents District 81 and is entering his second term.  He was an early supporter of those who felt their rights were being violated by the DeKalb County School Board and he penned a letter to the Superintendent stating his concern about the manner in which the vote was handled. 
 
Get the Cell Out - Atlanta supports Rep. Holcomb's efforts to ban the gifts, free meals and other perks that the state government employees enjoy now that may influence the way they vote on issues critical to the future of our state, such as the wireless frontier and how the lives and property values of so many people may be adversely affected if it is not brought until control.
 
Thank you Rep. Holcomb for your fight to keep honesty and integrity in our government!
 
Rep. Scott Holcomb
(D - Atlanta)
REP. SCOTT HOLCOMB ON ETHICS:
"A few weeks ago, I announced my support for House Speaker David Ralston's promise to craft legislation to end all lobbyist gifts to legislators. I am pleased that the Speaker has expressed his commitment to change the way business is done in the Georgia General Assembly. The people of Georgia spoke very clearly on July 31st and Republicans and Democrats agreed on the need for reform. Every voter wants to know that legislators at the General Assembly are working on behalf of the people and not for the benefit of their own pocketbooks, frequent flyer accounts, or stomachs. Ending all lobbyist gifts is an important step in restoring public trust in government. The amount of money that lobbyists spend on elected officials is simply astonishing. I am delighted with the seriousness of the Speaker's proposal and I will be very happy to co-sponsor legislation to this effect. I would like to see the law ban overseas trips, weekend getaways to fancy resorts, golf outings, sports tickets, and even meals. As any economist will tell you, there's no such thing as a free lunch. Legislators receive per diem from Georgia's taxpayers, so they should pay for their own meals from now on.
 
"Speaker Ralston has promised to convene a study group to examine other states' best practices regarding gift bans. The group should get started right away so that legislation can be ready to go on day 1 of the next legislative session. The solution is really quite simple so it should not take long to study, draft, and implement the changes. To that end, the new law should go into effect on the day it is signed by Governor Deal. 
 
"I also urge the formation of a study group to enhance the enforcement powers of the Georgia Government Transparency and Campaign Finance Commission as part of the reform effort. These changes have the potential to make things better. I will finish my first term in January and I was amazed at how things 'work' at the Capitol. Reform is long overdue and while these measures won't fix all the problems at the Gold Dome, they should make for better policy making."

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Virtual Schools on the Horizon in DeKalb? The Answer is Yes, if State Legislators Have Their Way!

(click headline for full story)

Virtual schools and real profits: Industry shapes state policies

2:44 am September 5, 2012, by Maureen Downey

 

Will DeKalb's future classrooms look more like this?  Look out
for the upstart of more online charter schools, funded with the same
tax dollar allocations but without all that pesky overhead!  More money
for top level administrators, less money to actually help children learn.

The AJC "Get Schooled" blog (excepts in article below) shows a disturbing trend
 toward a school type that does not appear to be supported by any true results.

 

The Portland Press Herald and Maine Sunday Telegram published an impressive investigation on a trend that we are seeing in Georgia:  For-profit online k-12 schools “aiding” legislators in writing laws that create a demand and favorable climate for their product.

One of the changes pushed by the for-profit online sector: Statewide requirements that all students take at least one online course. We saw that effort here in Georgia.   Senate Bill 289 initially mandated that all Georgia high school students complete at least one online course starting in 2014.

But as passed and signed by the governor, the law says districts have to make online courses available to their students and increase options for online learning.

The law states:

The State Board of Education shall establish rules and regulations to maximize the number of students, beginning with students entering ninth grade in the 2014-2015 school year, who complete prior to graduation at least one course containing online learning.

(some text here omitted ... if interested, you can read the complete story here)

The Portland newspaper probe also looked at the performance of students taking online courses:
In Pennsylvania, where some 30,000 students are enrolled in virtual schools at an average cost of $10,000 per student, pupils scored 13 percent worse in reading and 24 percent worse in math than students at ordinary public schools, according to a 2011 study by Stanford University’s Center for Research on Education Outcomes. The researchers broke out the data for separate student groups — those poor enough to qualify for free or reduced lunch, those still learning to speak English, grade repeaters, blacks and Hispanics — and compared them to their counterparts at ordinary charter schools. “In every subgroup with significant effects,” they reported, “cyber charter performance is lower than the brick-and-mortar performance.”

The Stanford study may have helped prompt The New York Times to conduct an investigation of K12 Inc.’s virtual charter schools later that year, which concluded that the company “tries to squeeze profits from public school dollars by raising enrollment, increasing teacher workload and lowering standards.”

At the K12-managed Agora Cyber Charter School in Pennsylvania — which reportedly generated $72 million in revenues — the Times found: 
  • 60 percent of students were behind grade level in math,
  • nearly 50 percent were behind in reading and
  •  a third were not graduating on time:

“Hundreds of children, from kindergartners to seniors, withdraw within months after they enroll.”

The company spent $681,000 lobbying in the state between 2007 and the end of last year.
Whenever posters here (AJC's Get Schooled blog) question online education, industry folks complain that they are resisting innovation and defending the status quo.  But lobbyists writing laws that promote and protect the interests and profits of their industries over the well-being and welfare of taxpayers should be resisted.

The investigations by the Portland papers and The New York Times will be followed by similar exposés across the country. And the reason is simple:  For-profit education, whether k-12 or college, has two goals that can end up at odds. One is to educate students and the other is to make money. When the latter lags, the former suffers.


Online learning certainly has a growing role in education, but that role can’t be defined by the industry. It has to serve the education needs of students rather than the profit margins of providers.

–From Maureen Downey, for the AJC Get Schooled blog

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

GTCO-ATL Blog Posts Submitted to OpenCongress.org in Support of HR 6358, the Cell Phone "Right to Know" Act

(click headline for full text.)  The website for Open Congress asked for relevent blog posts in support of HR6358, the national Cell Phone "Right to Know" Act.  We submitted several of our blog posts for consideration and received the following reply via email:

From
writeus@opencongress.org

 
Aug. 28, 2012
 

Ticket #9675: relevent blog posts

Your request (#9675) has been received, and is being reviewed by our support staff.
To review the status of the request and add additional comments, follow the link below:
http://support.opencongress.org/tickets/9675


Get the Cell Out - Atlanta, Aug 28 03:06 (EDT):Relevant blog posts for HR 6358
http://www.getthecelloutatl.com/#!/2012/08/breaking-news-cellphone-right-to-know.html
http://www.getthecelloutatl.com/#!/2012/08/gao-to-fcc-its-time-to-solve-mystery-of.html
http://www.getthecelloutatl.com/#!/2012/08/letter-to-our-us-congressional-leaders.html

Monday, September 3, 2012

DeKalb School Board Draws Scrutiny; SACS Needs Our Help!



View from the audience at a DeKalb County School Board Work Session last year where some members of Get the Cell Out - Atlanta spoke up for other schools outside of their own districts in a show of unity against the board's vote to place cell towers on school grounds. 

(View this story by clicking headline)

View full AJC article here:  DeKalb school board draws scrutiny  By Ty Tagami
(reprinted in part with permission) The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Posted: 5:53 p.m. Thursday, Aug. 30, 2012

An accrediting agency wants the DeKalb County school board to answer allegations that it has mismanaged its oversight of the system and ignored key financial responsibilities.

The Southern Association of Colleges and Schools (SACS) said it’s received dozens of complaints from a broad spectrum of people in DeKalb. Parents, public officials and school staffers have alleged everything from financial mismanagement to undue influence in hiring — all while the school system faces a financial crisis.

“The allegation is they’re getting involved in areas that aren’t their responsibility, and then in the areas that are their responsibility, they’re not being effective,” said Mark Elgart, president and chief executive officer of AdvancED, the parent company of SACS.

In a letter recieved by school officials Wednesday, SACS said there is “significant concern” about whether DeKalb is meeting “at least” two of five accreditation standards. SACS gave DeKalb 30 days to respond, and will then investigate and issue a report.

According to GTCO-ATL calculations, this gives us until Friday, Sept. 28, to forward letters or other forms of proof to back up what is being claimed in these allegations.  Please help us in this effort by compiling your own proof of violations of DeKalb's school policies or by writing letters that backup the claims of mismanagement and ignoring key financial responsibilities. 

You may send this information to SACS at:
 
Southern Association of Colleges and Schools
Attn:  Mark Elgart, President and CEO, AdvanceED
cc:  Mr. Paul Reviere, Chairman, SACS
Regional Headquarters
1866 Southern Lane
Decatur, Georgia 30033-4097
 
FAX: 404-679-4556 
 
You may also fill out this simple "Contact Us" form
if your comments are brief: 
 
Or, send an email to:  contactus@advanc-ed.org
 
“I don’t see where we violated any policy,” school board chairman Eugene Walker said. He said he wants to consult the 9-member school board before issuing any detailed response. He also said he needed more details than provided in the 3-page letter.

“They need to show some evidence of these things,” Walker said.

The allegations are from about 50 people over the past year, Elgart said.

SACS also has its own concerns. For instance, Elgart said, state audits over the past five years show the board spent 10 times more than it budgeted for day-to-day legal expenses — costs that were easily anticipated.

“One of the problems is the board has two law firms on retainer because they couldn’t agree on one,” Elgart said. “It is highly irregular for a school system to have two law firms doing the work of one.”
Elgart said it’s unusual for SACS to send a letter like this. It does so each year with perhaps 1 percent of the school systems in the 38 states where it operates, he said.

(For the rest of this article in the AJC, click here.)

(To read the letter from SACS in its entirety, click here.)
 
Please forward a copy of your statement (or excerpt from what you decided to send) to us
at sayno2celltowers@yahoo.com so that we may reprint it on this website
(without your name included to protect your privacy). 

Sharing your comments is optional but it will help to encourage others to do the same.  Thanks!

Saturday, September 1, 2012

Corruption in DeKalb's Planning and Permitting Departments AND Nepotism in the Elections Office

(click headline to watch video news report)

CBS Atlanta's Wendy Saltzman uncovers more corruption in DeKalb County.  Watch her recent report about the Planning and Development department accepting bribes in exchange for permitting buildings that were recently declined for permits.  So, does T-mobile hold permits for cell towers at our schools?  We are still seeking the answer to that question.





And, in the voter registration office for oversight of our elections: